Section 40A(2)

Home / Glossary / Tax / Section 40A(2)

Introduction

Section 40A(2) of Income Tax Act, 1961 curbs unreasonable payments businesses make to their stakeholders or related parties, preventing tax evasion, profiteering, and financial mismanagement. It applies when an income tax assessing officer suspects that an organization’s owners or shareholders have directed unreasonably high payments to certain individuals or entities known as “specified persons.” The act scrutinizes such transactions to prevent organizations from improperly siphoning funds and claiming excessive deductions.

Key Objectives of Section 40A(2)

Preventing Profiteering and Financial Misconduct: Section 40A(2) aims to eliminate any large payouts to related entities that are beyond fair value.
Restricting Unjustified Deductions: It addresses excessive deductions claimed by diverting funds to specified persons.
Ensuring Fair Market Practices: This section enforces fair value practices, preventing related entities from claiming unjustified benefits.

You may also want to know Agricultural Income

Applicability of Section 40A(2) Deductions

According to Section 40A(2), deductions are disallowed under these conditions:

Payments for Any Expense: If payment has been made for an expenditure, irrespective of its nature.
Payments to Specified Persons: Any payments made or to be made to “specified persons” for expenses.
Excessive Amounts Over Fair Value: Payments that significantly exceed the fair value of goods, services, or facilities are subject to scrutiny.

Under these conditions, the income tax officer has the authority to investigate and disallow such payments if they are deemed excessive or unreasonable.

Important Definitions in Section 40A(2)

1. Assessee with Substantial Interest

Voting Rights: An individual holding more than 20% of the voting rights in a company throughout the year.
Profit Share: Any person entitled to at least 20% of the business profits is classified as having substantial interest.

2. Specified Persons

The law includes entities like directors of companies, partners in firms, members of a Hindu Undivided Family (HUF), and relatives of such individuals as “specified persons.”
Related Parties: Individuals or entities with substantial interest, including spouses, parents, siblings, and children, fall under “specified persons.”

Practical Examples for Clarity

Example 1: Suppose a company’s director holds 40% of another company and frequently transacts with it. If payments to the director exceed the fair market value, they may be investigated.
Example 2: If the sibling of a director owns 22% of another entity’s shares and the two companies engage in financial transactions, Section 40A(2) comes into play.

You may also want to know Property Tax

Real-Life Application: Preventing Nepotism in Financial Deals

Section 40A(2) highlights its preventive role in cases like that of ICICI Bank’s former CEO, Chanda Kochhar, who allegedly favored a related entity. While the case is ongoing, it underscored the importance of scrutinizing transactions that may benefit insiders at the expense of fairness.

Impact on Taxpayers: Filing and Compliance

All payments falling within Section 40A(2) must be disclosed in the tax returns if such expenses are claimed for deductions. Taxpayers should ensure that transactions with specified persons align with fair market value to avoid disallowances and additional tax liabilities.

Conclusion

Section 40A(2) reinforces financial integrity by ensuring that payments to related entities or individuals are fair and justifiable. It underscores the importance of compliance, preventing companies from diverting funds improperly and enabling fair tax practices.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the purpose of Section 40A(2)?

Section 40A(2) prevents taxpayers from claiming excessive deductions through unjustified payments to related parties.

Who is classified as a "specified person"?

Specified persons include directors, partners, members of HUFs, and relatives with substantial interest in the business.

How does Section 40A(2) define "substantial interest"?

A person holding over 20% of voting rights or receiving 20% of the profits is considered to have substantial interest.

Can the Income Tax Department investigate under Section 40A(2)?

Yes, if payments to specified persons exceed fair value, they may be disallowed or investigated.

Are family members considered related under Section 40A(2)?

Yes, close relatives, including spouses, parents, and siblings, are classified as specified persons if they have a financial interest in the business.