Introduction

As an Indian, you must be familiar with the word “Fixed Deposit,” doesn’t it? Fixed deposits used to be the best investment option in India, but why is there a sudden change in perception with topics like FD vs Stocks? Are stocks really that worthy? Let’s break this down. 

Financial literacy is increasing in India and individuals are now getting to know the common difference between saving and investing. The stock market and Fixed deposits are currently two of the most popular investment options. Believe it or not, currently, investing in the stock market is more profitable than investing in fixed deposits. On the other hand, FDs are safer compared to stocks. 

So, where should you invest? Let’s explore the FD vs Stock comparison in detail. 

What is a Fixed Deposit?

A Fixed Deposit (FD) is a financial instrument offered by banks and financial institutions where you deposit a lump sum of money for a fixed tenure at a predetermined interest rate. In return, the bank pays you interest, either periodically or at maturity. FDs are known for their safety and guaranteed returns, making them a popular choice for conservative investors. The interest rates on FDs are typically higher than those on savings accounts but lower than potential returns from the stock market.

What is the Stock Market?

The stock market is a marketplace where shares of publicly traded companies are bought and sold. Investors purchase stocks (also known as shares or equities) to gain ownership in companies, with the expectation of earning returns through price appreciation and dividends. The stock market is dynamic, with prices fluctuating based on various factors like company performance, economic conditions, and investor sentiment.

You may also want to know Best Investment Tips for Newcomers in the Stock Market

Fixed Deposit vs Stock Market:

• Returns: Stocks have the potential for higher returns compared to FDs. While FDs offer a fixed deposit interest rate, stocks can provide substantial gains if the company performs well. However, there’s also the risk of losses if the stock price falls.
• Risk: The stock market is inherently risky due to its volatility. Prices can change rapidly based on market conditions. In contrast, FDs are low-risk, offering guaranteed returns, making them a safer option for conservative investors.
• Liquidity: Stocks offer higher liquidity, as they can be traded during market hours, allowing investors to buy or sell shares quickly. FDs, however, lock in your money for a fixed period, and early withdrawal can lead to penalties.
• Tax Implications: The tax authorities tax interest earned from FDs, while they apply a lower rate to long-term gains from stocks and tax short-term gains according to the investor’s income tax slab.
• Investment Horizon: Investors generally consider stocks for long-term growth, as they can yield significant returns over time despite short-term volatility. For short- to medium-term goals, FDs suit those prioritizing capital preservation.

Comparing Risk Factors

• Risk in Fixed Deposits (FDs): Investors consider FDs one of the safest investment options because they offer guaranteed returns. They protect the principal amount and provide a fixed interest rate, ensuring you know exactly what you’ll receive at maturity. The primary risk with FDs is interest rate risk, where the interest rates might be lower than inflation, reducing the real value of returns over time.
• Risk in Stock Market Investments: Investing in stocks involves significantly higher risk compared to FDs. Stock prices can fluctuate widely due to factors like market conditions, economic changes, and company performance. This volatility means that while there’s potential for high returns, there’s also a risk of losing a substantial portion of your investment, especially in the short term.

Which is Safer?

FDs are undoubtedly safer due to their guaranteed returns and principal protection. Stocks, though riskier, can offer much higher returns if the investment is successful. The choice between the two depends on the investor’s risk tolerance and financial goals.

Returns: Fixed and Variable

• Fixed Returns from FDs: FDs offer fixed returns, which means you know the exact interest rate and the amount you’ll receive at the end of the tenure. These returns are predictable and stable, making FDs a good option for those who prefer certainty in their investments.
• Potential Returns from Stocks: Stocks offer variable returns, which can be much higher than those from FDs. The growth potential is significant, especially over the long term, as companies expand and increase in value. However, these returns are not guaranteed and depend on market performance. Investors must be prepared for the possibility of both gains and losses.

FD vs Stocks: Historical Performance Comparison

Historically, the stock market has outperformed FDs over the long term, but with higher volatility. FDs provide lower but stable returns, making them suitable for conservative investors. Stocks, while riskier, are more suitable for those looking for higher growth and who can handle market fluctuations.

Liquidity and Investment Horizon

• Liquidity of FDs: FDs are less liquid than stocks because they have a fixed tenure. Withdrawing money before maturity usually incurs a penalty, reducing the overall returns. This makes FDs less flexible, especially if you need access to your money before the term ends.
• Liquidity in Stock Investments: Stocks are highly liquid, as they can be bought or sold on the stock market at any time during trading hours. This liquidity allows investors to quickly respond to market changes or personal financial needs. However, selling stocks in a down market may result in a loss.

FD vs Stocks: Suitable Investment Horizons

FDs suit short to medium-term investment goals focused on capital preservation. Stocks work best for long-term horizons, maximizing growth potential and smoothing out short-term volatility over time.

Tax Implications

• Tax on FD Interest Income: The interest earned on FDs is fully taxable as per the investor’s income tax slab. This means that the tax can significantly reduce the effective return on your FD investment, especially if you fall into a higher tax bracket.
• Taxation of Stock Market Gains: The holding period determines the tax on stock market gains: you pay 15% on short-term capital gains (for stocks held less than a year) and 10% on long-term gains (for stocks held more than a year) beyond the ₹1 lakh exemption. Dividends received are also taxable, though the tax treatment can vary.

Fixed Deposit vs Stock Market: Tax-saving Strategies

For FDs, tax-saving options include investing in tax-saving FDs with a 5-year lock-in period, which offers deductions under Section 80C of the Income Tax Act. For stocks, long-term investing can reduce tax liabilities, and investing in equity-linked savings schemes (ELSS) can also provide tax benefits under Section 80C.

Who Should Invest in FDs?

FDs are best suited for conservative investors who prioritize capital preservation and prefer guaranteed returns over potentially higher, but uncertain, gains. This includes retirees, individuals nearing retirement, or anyone who requires a stable and secure investment option to meet short to medium-term financial goals. FDs are also ideal for those with low risk tolerance who prefer a predictable income stream.

Scenarios Where FDs are Beneficial:

• Short-Term Financial Goals: FDs are ideal for meeting short-term goals like saving for a down payment on a house, a child’s education, or an upcoming vacation, where the investment horizon is a few months to a few years.
• Emergency Fund: An FD can serve as a reliable part of an emergency fund, providing a safe place to store money with the option of premature withdrawal if needed, albeit with a penalty.
• Risk-Averse Individuals: For those who cannot afford to lose any of their principles and prefer the peace of mind that comes with knowing exactly how much they will receive at maturity, FDs are a good choice.

Who Should Invest in Stocks?

Stocks are suitable for investors with a higher risk tolerance who are willing to accept market volatility in exchange for the potential of higher returns. This includes younger investors with a longer time horizon, individuals looking for growth opportunities, and those who can afford to invest money without needing immediate access. Investors who are comfortable with market ups and downs and aim to build wealth over the long term will find stocks ideal.

Scenarios Where Stocks are Beneficial:

• Long-Term Wealth Building: Stocks are an excellent choice for long-term financial goals like retirement planning, where the investor can benefit from the compounding growth of stock investments over time.
• Capital Growth: Investors looking for capital appreciation, rather than just preserving their wealth, often turn to stocks as they have the potential to deliver higher returns compared to FDs or other fixed-income investments.
• Diversification: Stocks can be a crucial component of a diversified investment portfolio, helping to balance risk and reward by providing growth potential alongside more stable investments like FDs or bonds.

Comparative Analysis of FD vs Stocks 

Diversification: Combining FD vs Stocks

Diversification involves spreading investments across different asset classes, such as FDs and stocks, to manage risk and enhance returns. A balanced portfolio that includes both FDs and stocks can provide the stability of fixed returns through FDs while allowing for the growth potential of stocks. This approach can help mitigate the risk of stock market volatility while still offering the opportunity for higher returns over time.

You may also want to know How to Invest in Stock Market with Limited Capital?

How to Diversify Between FD vs Stocks?

• Risk Management: Allocating a portion of your portfolio to FDs protects some of your money from market fluctuations, providing a safety net, while you invest the rest in stocks to aim for higher growth.
• Age-Based Allocation: Younger investors may allocate a larger portion of their portfolio to stocks, given their longer investment horizon, and a smaller portion to FDs. As they age and approach retirement, they may shift more towards FDs to reduce risk and secure their capital.
• Income and Growth: For investors seeking both income and growth, a mix of FDs for steady interest income and stocks for potential capital gains can be an effective strategy. This combination can help meet immediate financial needs while also allowing for future wealth accumulation.

Wrapping Up! 

So, which is the best investment option according to you? Investing in fixed deposits or the stock market solely depends on the financial goals and risk factors. If you want a safe and easy investment Fixed deposits are great. However, if you are looking for higher growth considering the risk factors, stocks can be the option to move forward.  

Hang on, stocks are not the only investment option that comes with higher returns, you can invest in Mutual Funds with returns similar to stocks (even better returns in some cases). Research well, set your financial goals, and start investing! 

Open a Demat Account with Jainam if your investment plan is with Stocks or Mutual Funds.